Need to Make a Payment or Report a Claim?

Below is a list of our personal insurance carriers, their websites and phone numbers.
If you need to make a payment or a claim on your personal insurance, you can contact your carrier directly. If you do not see your carrier listed or have any questions, please do not hesitate to call us directly, 315-457-1830.
Insurance CarrierPhone Number
Adirondack1-877-629-8003
Allstate1-877-810-2920
Andover Companies978-475-3300 or 800-225-0770
Broome Co-Operative607-321-2655 or 866-921-BCIC
Central Co-Operative315-635-7606
Central Mutual419-238-1010
Chubb1-866-324-8222
Cincinnati888-242-8811 or 513-870-2000
Dryden Mutual607-844-8106 or 800-724-0560
Erie & Niagara716-632-5433
Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty607-387-6800
Fulmont Mutual518-762-3171
Grange866-550-9222
Genesee Patrons585-343-7307
Hanover508-855-1000
Hartford860-547-5000
Kemper866-860-9348
Leatherstocking Cooperative607-547-2007
Madison Mutual618-656-3410 or 800-766-MMIC
Merchants Mutual1-800-462-1077
Metlife1-800-METLIFE
Midstate Mutual1-800-826-8520
Mutual Benefit (MBG)/a>1-800-283-3531
National General1-888-293-5108
Nazareth Mutual800-321-6783
New York Central Mutual1-800-234-6926
North Country Insurance800-847-7030 or 315-788-4730
Otsego Mutual607-965-8211
Preferred Mutual800-333-7642
Progressive/ASI1-833-616-5448
Pure Insurance888-813-7873
R.T. Specialty312-784-6001
Safeco1-800-332-3226
Security Mutual607-257-5000
Selective Flood877-348-0552
Sterling Insurance518-234-2521
State Auto877-722-5246
Travelers1-800-842-5075
Utica National800-598-8422
Wayne Co-Operative315-923-2861 or 800-724-1648