• Need to Make a Payment or Report a Claim?

    Below is a list of our personal insurance carriers, their websites and phone numbers. If you need to make a payment or a claim on your personal insurance, you can contact your carrier directly. If you do not see your carrier listed or have any questions, please do not hesitate to call us directly, 315-457-1830.
    Insurance Carrier Phone Number
    Adirondack 1-877-629-8003
    Allstate 1-877-810-2920
    Andover Companies 978-475-3300 or 800-225-0770
    Broome Co-Operative 607-321-2655 or 866-921-BCIC
    Central Co-Operative 315-635-7606
    Central Mutual 419-238-1010
    Chubb 1-866-324-8222
    Cincinnati 888-242-8811 or 513-870-2000
    Dryden Mutual 607-844-8106 or 800-724-0560
    Erie & Niagara 716-632-5433
    Finger Lakes Fire & Casualty 607-387-6800
    Fulmont Mutual 518-762-3171
    Grange 866-550-9222
    Genesee Patrons 585-343-7307
    Hanover 508-855-1000
    Hartford 860-547-5000
    Kemper 866-860-9348
    Leatherstocking Cooperative 607-547-2007
    Madison Mutual 618-656-3410 or 800-766-MMIC
    Merchants Mutual 1-800-462-1077
    Metlife 1-800-METLIFE
    Midstate Mutual 1-800-826-8520
    Mutual Benefit (MBG)/a> 1-800-283-3531
    National General 1-888-293-5108
    Nazareth Mutual 800-321-6783
    New York Central Mutual 1-800-234-6926
    North Country Insurance 800-847-7030 or 315-788-4730
    Otsego Mutual 607-965-8211
    Preferred Mutual 800-333-7642
    Progressive/ASI 1-833-616-5448
    Pure Insurance 888-813-7873
    R.T. Specialty 312-784-6001
    Safeco 1-800-332-3226
    Security Mutual 607-257-5000
    Selective Flood 877-348-0552
    Sterling Insurance 518-234-2521
    State Auto 877-722-5246
    Travelers 1-800-842-5075
    Utica National 800-598-8422
    Wayne Co-Operative 315-923-2861 or 800-724-1648